Skip to content

Power, politics and the individual

June 19, 2019

When we use or compete for power, how often do we reflect on the impact this has on individuals?

I have been corresponding recently with a contract manager in Iran – a deeply troubled country, struggling to recover from a turbulent past. As with so many parts of the Middle East, it suffered for many years from the the power politics of competing empires and their economic interests. Today, it suffers from internal tensions that spill over into regional and international confrontation.

My correspondent is dedicated to contract management. He has worked hard and industriously to raise his knowledge and competence. He would like nothng more than to continue that development and to contribute his expertise in a more settled environmant, where his skills can be used to much greater effect, generating social and economic value.

Potential employers in Europe and other parts of the Middle East recognize his capabilities. In recent months, he has had three job offers. On two occasions, work visas have been denied. In the third, the offer was withdrawn out of fear of sanctions. In every case, the issue is driven by the stand-off between the governments of Iran and the United States.

Power battles are a reality and we certainly cannot change them any time soon. But stories like this cause me to reflect on the fact that behind every power battle there are people – individuals whose lives are impacted, often quite fundamentally. All of us in contract and commercial management are potentially part of that power-based thinking – the terms and conditions we seek to impose (are they fair?), the negotiation strategies we adopt (are they win-win?), the way we handle supplier or customer relationships (are they equitable?).

To a degree, attempts to establish power are an inevitable consequence of competition and, within limits, can be productive and beneficial. But when we simply aim for power for its own sake, or use it without thought or to tip the balance unreasonably in our favor, it is not only destructive, but also creates tensions that may spill over into confrontation.

It is easy to shrug our shoulders and see this as someone else’s problem, or take the view that this is just the way of the world. But is it really the way we want the world to be? And even if our own individual efforts can only be small, cumultatively they would be large. Fairness and balance in contracting practices would deliver a tremendous social and economic benefit – and perhaps even start to influence areas of political thinking. In the end, I just hope that my Iranian correspondent – and many more like him – can realize his ambitions and be allowed the chance to contribute his talents to the world.

  1. Gordon Simpson permalink

    I have also corresponded with the same person in Iran for several years, mainly about all things Quantity Surveying and Contracts Management.
    Rarely in my long career in Construction Contract Management have I met an individual as dedicated to learning his profession as this particular human being; and I use the term human being deliberately in empathy with your thoughts above.
    The primary reason this individual strives to master his profession is to attain excellence in what he does for the benefit of his Profession and ultimately his wife and young family. However, he is repeatedly rejected by prospective employers because of his nationality; for NO other reason.
    So yes; he is a human being caught up in the turmoil that is the Middle East and is held back in his chosen career and ambitions for his family purely because he is Iranian!!!

  2. Mahmoud Khalifa permalink

    I am in full empathy with the man. I don’t know him but I know many Iranian who are very sincere in their work but struggling due to politics… Governments go to hell with your politics and leave the people to develop

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: